Group Project Description
A small group of students will research one of the "You be the Judge"
pages in the textbook (listed on the inside cover).
Each group summarizes its research in a website, and uses the
website as a visual aid during a 50-minute class presentation.
The website and class presentation are graded for the whole
group, although I reserve the right to adjust this grade
depending on individual contribution to the project.
Purpose
Research
- To start research, meet as
a group and divide responsibilities. Remember, these
responsibilities may change because some tasks are more
difficult than others. Read the Website Evaluation Rubric
below to figure out what needs to be done.
- Each of you will need a
Word file where you write comments, and copy information
found on websites, as well as web addresses. Do not print
out websites; it is a waste of time and paper. Learn to
copy and paste vital information. Become a digital pack rat.
- Do not limit yourself to
websites; use of statistical databases and refereed
journals. Remember, you are looking for hard evidence, not
just claims and opinions. Statistical databases:
- Another great source is a
new search engine
http://scholar.google.com/ (This is not a generic Google
search)
Web design
- The most important
guideline in developing the web site is the rubric. Make
sure you read and understand it.
- Feel free to use any
web development software. Here is a short
manual for Dreamweaver that I recommend
to use.
- See sample websites made by
students in the past:
-
Should technology lead the quest for better schools?
-
Does school violence warrant the use of zero
tolerance policies?
- Always keep a back-up copy
of your website, and all materials that go into it. Computer
disasters do happen. Use a zip disk or a flash drive to keep
your information, because a floppy disk is too small and too
slow for a website.
- On the day of presentation,
upload your website, and bring a disk, just in case.
Paste the link to your site on the Websites forum; type the
group number and the topic in the subject, and simply paste
the link in the message, so people can look at your site and
discuss it.
-
Caution: do not simply cut and paste a text from
other websites; this would be an instance of plagiarism. If
you quote someone, make a proper reference.
- When making links, hide
actual web addresses in your links; don't make them visible
(see samples below). References to paper sources should be
placed on each page of your website according to the
APA style. Reference to on-line source should be placed
as close as possible to the quoted text, for example:
- According to a Harvard professor
James Smith, public
schooling has outlived its usefulness.
- The main argument in support of
school uniforms arises from concern for school safety,
as one parent advocacy group suggests (Parents
for School Safety).
|
Group Project Rubric
Category
|
Advanced (8-10 points each)
|
Proficient (5-7 points)
|
Developing (1-4 points)
|
Introduction to the issue
|
- Introduces the issue
effectively and clearly
- The audience is told clearly
what to expect (i.e., the parts of the presentation,
a roadmap as to how the presentation will be ordered)
- Defines key terminology
- Shows debate's
significance: Why this topic is important? (statistics,
multimedia, etc. that help set the context) |
- Introduces the topic
- The audience is told what to
expect
- Defines some terminology, yet
important terms are left undefined
- Shows debate's significance
(mainly anecdotal evidence) |
- Introduction is confusing
- The audience is not told what
to expect
- Uses terminology without
definitions
-Show debate's significance by
making a claim that is insignificant |
Yes
side
|
- Each point is clearly
explained and supported by factual evidence
- Provides at least 3
refereed (peer-reviewed) journal articles
- Includes other
scholarly sources (book chapters, etc.) |
- Most points are
explained and supported by factual evidence
- Provides 2 refereed journal
articles or book chapters |
- Points are stated but not
explained
- One or no refereed journal
articles or book chapters used, relies mainly on
non-scholarly sources |
No
side
|
Same as Yes side |
Same as Yes side |
Same as Yes side |
Media
|
- Group develops a website with
a logical structure, consistent layout and adequate
graphical elements
- Either video or audio media
is used in addition to the website
- Website is properly uploaded
and functional |
- Group uses PowerPoint,
Publisher or similar presentation, with a logical structure,
consistent layout and adequate graphical elements |
- Paper-based visual aids |
Class presentation |
-Informative (Tell the audience
something it does not know already, and will find useful).
-Organized (There is an
apparent plan, structure, order).
-Engaging (The audience is
actively involved).
|
Two the the three criteria met
|
One of the three criteria met |
Total |
50 |
35 |
20 |
|
| |
Quick links:
Text book website
Sadker.com
Blackboard
Email instructor
APA format
|